What’s in Print

Tank fleet profits continue slide

(View a PDF of this article with the tables included or search the archive of previous reports.)

For the third year in a row, tank truck carriers struggled to make a profit. However, most fleets were able to eke out at least a small revenue increase in 2007, and productivity improvements continued.

Just over 60% of the carriers participating in this year's Bulk Transporter Annual Gross Revenue Report posted higher revenues. That was down slightly from about 63% of participating fleets in 2006. In addition, operating ratios worsened for 78% of the participants in this report.

What ate up profits? Fuel played a big role, surpassing labor as the largest expense for some tank truck carriers. Overall, the trucking industry spent $112.6 billion on fuel in 2007 as the price of a gallon of diesel topped $3.30. Among other factors eating at profits were rising healthcare costs, increased vehicle purchase and maintenance costs, and inflation in the general economy.

Economic turbulence brought more consolidation of the tank truck industry in 2007. For instance, Trimac Transportation Services purchased the business and assets of Logistics Express Inc. A&R Logistics Inc (holding company for Transport, A&R Global Logistics, and A&R Packaging and Distribution) acquired Alliance Logistics Inc and MCB Services.

Top 10 tank truck carriers found profits just as elusive as the rest of the industry. While all but one of the Top 10 posted revenue increases from 2006 to 2007, just two showed improved operating ratios.

Quality Distribution Inc maintained its hold on the top spot, followed closely by the Trimac Group of Companies and Kenan Advantage Group. Rounding out the Top 10 were Superior Bulk Logistics Inc, Groendyke Transport Inc, A&R Transport Inc, Enterprise Transportation Co, Schneider National Bulk Carriers, Foodliner/Quest Liner Inc, and Tankstar USA Inc.

Combined Top 10 revenues were $3.2 billion in 2007, a small improvement over 2006. Top 10 revenues in 2007 accounted for 53.8% of the total in the report.

The Top 25 carriers had $4.6 billion in revenues, or 77% of the total represented in this report. That was an increase over the $4.4 billion in revenues reported by the Top 25 in 2006.

Total 2007 revenues for all 77 tank truck carriers in this report were $6,013,994,463. In contrast, the 80 carriers in the 2006 report accounted for a combined total of $5,894,691,407.

Average revenue in 2007 was $77,959,737, up $4.2 million from the average of $73,683,642 in 2006. The average grew by the same amount from 2005 to 2006. The median carrier on the list, the one with an equal number of carriers above and below it, had revenues of $33,200,000. In 2006, the median carrier revenue was $31,180,000.

Operating ratios for both 2007 and 2006 were supplied by 59 of the carriers in this report. Just 14 — less than a quarter — showed improvement over the previous year. The operating ratio represents operating expenses as a percentage of revenue.

Thirty-seven had operating ratios between 95.0% and 99.9% (compared with 36 in 2006), and one had a ratio above 100%. Ratios between 90.0% and 94.9% were reported by 21 carriers, down two from the previous year.

Most of the fleets participating in the 2007 report submitted data used to calculate tractor revenues. These numbers give an indication of productivity levels. The average for 2007 was $207,109, a healthy increase over the $180,723 average in 2006.

Eight of the Top 10 reported tractor revenues, averaging $198,331. This was a small increase over the $195,781 average reported by the Top 10 in 2006.

The best productivity (tractor revenue of $367,642) came from a Northeast petroleum hauler. The lowest tractor revenue ($96,037) was posted by a mixed tank fleet operator based in the Midwest.

The number of petroleum carriers exceeding the $300,000 mark for tractor revenues continued to increase in 2007. Average revenue per tractor for a representative group of eight petroleum haulers was $270,491, up from the previous year's average of $238,158. The lowest tractor revenue posted by a petroleum fleet was $173,757.

Ten chemical haulers accounted for average revenue per tractor of $203,795, up from $196,571 in 2006. Chemical tractor revenue ranged from a high of $335,802 down to $145,348.

Average tractor revenue for five dry bulk specialists was $173,082, a healthy increase from a $155,311 average in 2006. Dry bulk tractor revenue ranged from a high of $218,856 to a low of $133,059.

Among three carriers that focus on transporting liquid and dry foods, tractor revenue averaged $178,738, a good increase over the 2006 average of $156,820. The high for the category was $188,344.

Many of the figures here are from preaudited reports, and some may include nonbulk revenues or revenues from subsidiary tank truck carriers. In all cases, the numbers were supplied directly to Bulk Transporter. The staff greatly appreciates the cooperation of all who helped in the preparation of this report.

To see the full 2007 Gross Revenue Report click here.

Alphabetical cross-index of listed carriers

Fleet nameRank
A&R Transport Inc 6
Andrews Transport LP 18
Apex Bulk Commodities 24
Atlantic Bulk Carrier Corp 50
Barnett Transportation 58
Blue Flash Express LLC 52
Bork Transport of Illinois 53
Brewer Petroleum Service Inc 70
Buesing Bulk Transport 60
Bulkmatic Transport Co 14
Carbon Express Inc 68
CLI Transport LP 45
Coal City Cob Company Inc 42
Commercial Transport Inc 63
CTL Transportation LLC 29
Dillon Transport 47
Distribution Technologies Inc 17
Dixon Brothers Inc 55
J P Donmoyer Inc 43
Dupré Logistics LLC 12
Eagle Transport Corp 19
Enterprise Transportation Co 7
Herman R Ewell Inc 48
Fleet Transit Inc 56
Food Express Inc 46
Foodliner/Quest Liner Inc 9
Gless Brothers Inc 51
Goodman Tank Lines Inc 64
Groendyke Transport Inc 5
R O Harrell Inc 61
Hazmat Environmental Group 49
Highway Transport Inc 33
Hillman Companies 57
Horizon Tank Lines Inc 66
Iowa Tanklines Inc 41
Island Transportation Corp 32
J&M Tank Lines 40
J&S Transport Co Inc 76
Jasa Transit Inc 69
K-Limited Carrier Ltd 62
Jack B Kelley Inc 23
Kenan Advantage Group 3
Langer Transport Corp 36
Linden Bulk Transportation Co Inc 21
M C Tank Transport Inc 59
P S Marston Associates 54
Martin Transport Inc 20
McKenzie Tank Lines Inc 27
Miller Transporters Inc 16
Mission Petroleum Carriers Inc 26
J P Noonan Transportation Inc 31
Northwest Tank Lines 39
PAR Trucking Inc 77
Penn Tank Lines Inc 25
Quality Distribution Inc 1
Reliable Liquid Transport Inc 65
Saraguay Petroleum Corp 73
Schilli Bulk Carriers 35
Schneider National Bulk Carriers 8
Service Transport Company 28
Herbert R Shipley Inc 75
F T Silfies Inc 44
Slay Transportation Co Inc 13
Stardust Transportation LLC 74
Superior Bulk Logistics Inc 4
Switzer Tank Lines Inc 71
Tankstar USA Inc 10
Terpening Trucking Co Inc 67
Tidewater Transit Co Inc 34
Transgas Inc 72
Transport Service Co 11
TransWood Carriers Inc 15
Trimac Group of Companies 2
United Petroleum Transports Inc 30
Usher Transport Inc 38
Cliff Viessman Inc 22
Wynne Transport Service 37
TAGS: Tank Fleets
Hide comments

Comments

  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Publish